Art Tatum & Roy Eldridge: Night and Day


NIght and Day


Art Tatum (piano) and Roy Eldridge (trumpet)


The Tatum Group Masterpieces Vol. 2 (Pablo 2045-425)

Buy Track


Art Tatum (piano), Roy Eldridge (trumpet), John Simmons (bass), Alvin Stoller (drums).

Composed by Cole Porter


Recorded: Los Angeles, March 29, 1955


Rating: 96/100 (learn more)

Art Tatum had performed with Roy Eldridge back in 1944 at a famous concert by the Esquire All-Stars, but their paths rarely crossed afterwards until Norman Granz brought them into the studio a decade later as part of the producer's "Group Masters" project. The idea of matching Tatum with top-notch horn players sounded fine in theory, but with some exceptions, found the pianist playing over rather than with his colleagues. Yet his outing on "Night and Day" with trumpeter Roy Eldridge coheres better than one might expect. Eldridge was no stranger to battles on the bandstand, but here he focuses on sheer swing rather than try to match Tatum note-for-note. Simmons and Stoller are energized by his presence, and create a more supple pulse than one usually finds on the Granz-Tatum projects. The pianist is hardly chastened by this change of affairs, and continues to throw out his baroque runs and elaborate reconfigurations, but even he is infused with the groove. This may not quite match the impromptu give-and-take that Tatum achieved after hours in casual jams, but it comes closer than most of his studio sessions to capturing that ambiance.

Reviewer: Ted Gioia

Tags: · · · ·

Comments are closed.