Louis Armstrong: Some Of These Days

Track

Some Of These Days

Group

Louis Armstrong & His Orchestra

CD

Louis In New York (Columbia 46148)

Buy Track

Musicians:

Louis Armstrong (trumpet, vocals),

Homer Hobson (trumpet), Fred Robinson (trombone), Bert Curry, Crawford Wethington, Jimmy Strong (reeds), Gene Anderson (piano), Mancy Carr (banjo), Pete Briggs (tuba), Zutty Singleton (drums)

.

Composed by Shelton Brooks

.

Recorded: New York, September 10, 1929

Pops_in_ny

Rating: 95/100 (learn more)

With his classic big band recording of "I Can't Give You Anything But Love," the basic formula for Louis Armstrong's arrangements was set: melodic interpretation on trumpet, solo break by a member of the band, vocal solo, another solo break, then big final trumpet chorus. Now, there's nothing wrong with a working formula, especially—as in Louis' case—when you're the first person to do it. His version of the evergreen "Some Of These Days" was made fairly early in the series and in this case, the formula was turned inside out. It sounds like the band is reading a stock arrangement which means that there's more for them to do than just accompany Louis. Still, Louis gets all of the solo space he normally had, just in a different order. After the saxophone intro, he sings first, and since the song was fairly well-known, he takes a lot of liberties with it. In fact, it almost sounds like he's singing in the wrong key for the first half of his chorus, but he's just singing an adventuresome variation of the melody. After a clumsy break by Jimmy Strong, Louis plays his first trumpet solo. In contrast to the vocal, he's fairly conservative, using a set of symmetrical phrases and closing with a hoochie-coochie riff that was part of the arrangement. The saxes have a variation and the playing is about as clean as any of Louis' backing groups of this period. Louis' final solo is a dazzling display which covers the entire range of the horn and peaks with a sustained high D-flat. Louis didn't favor his low register much, and on the non-vocal take also included on the above CD, we can hear why: in the same spot, Louis moves to the lower register and he gets covered up by the saxes. Within a few years, recording techniques would improve and there would be less of these balance issues. What is surprising is that the non-vocal version was issued (mostly outside of the US) even with the balance problem. While not the equal of the vocal version, the instrumental take is worth a listen.

Reviewer: Thomas Cunniffe

Tags: · · ·


Comments are closed.